The Second World War marked a period of profound upheaval across South and Southeast Asia. Long-standing networks of mobility, commerce, and social connection that had linked the region were dramatically disrupted by the Japanese invasion of Burma in 1942. The end of the war brought little stability. The British Empire unraveled with remarkable speed, the Partition of India in 1947 unleashed unprecedented violence and displacement, and colonial authorities pursued bloody counterinsurgency campaigns in places like Malaya. These overlapping crises transformed the region’s political landscape, producing widespread uncertainty, displacement, and social dislocation. Emerging from this turbulent moment, newly independent states faced the formidable challenge of defining the boundaries of national belonging and recasting former imperial subjects as citizens within newly imagined political communities.
In Boats in a Storm: Law, Migration, and Decolonization in South and Southeast Asia, 1942–1962 (Stanford University Press, 2023), historian Kalyani Ramnath examines how decolonization, migration, and legal transformation reshaped the Indian Ocean world in the mid-twentieth century, making an important contribution to the historiography of mobility, citizenship, and postcolonial state formation.
I spoke with Kalyani Ramnath about the book’s major interventions, its place within Indian Ocean history, and what migrants’ experiences reveal about the transition from empire to nation-state.
–Tathagata Dutta, Editor at Large (Auburn University at Montgomery)

Tathagata Dutta (TD): Although our discussion will primarily center on your first monograph, Boats in a Storm, we hope to also gain glimpses of your intellectual journey. As I understand it, this book evolved from your PhD dissertation. However, it is evident that the legal world looms very large. Clearly, your training as a lawyer played a huge role, but perhaps your family background as well. In the preface, you briefly mention your grandmother and the stories she shared with you during your childhood. How do you think these two aspects influenced your research and writing?
Kalyani Ramnath (KR): Thank you, Tathagata, for having me on the Toynbee Prize Foundation interview. You asked me about what, in terms of background, went into making this book. The book is shaped by my training as a lawyer and subsequently, as a historian. I trained as a lawyer in India first. I studied law at the National Law School of India University in Bangalore, which had quite unusually for that time, a very robust, rigorous, and interdisciplinary program in law and the arts. This meant that we began our study of law by examining history, sociology, and economics. I remember my very first history course on the philosophy of history. We began with courses like that before moving on to torts, contracts, or corporate law. I think that gave me a certain perspective and sensibility about what law is, what it does in the world, and what it was like for people to encounter it. That sensibility is something that I tried to bring to my book.
After completing my training at NLS, I had the opportunity to spend a year at Yale Law School as a masters’ student. There, too, people were very interested in legal history and law and literature, two approaches for which the Yale program was very well known. I went back to teach legal history for a couple of years at NLS. And I think that’s where I recognized that this was possibly what I wanted to do for the rest of my life. Once I finished that teaching stint, I applied to doctoral programs in history.
I went into graduate school thinking I wanted to do a few things. I wanted to leverage the ease I had with legal materials and sources. I was also quite keen on working on South India. I felt like that was a good vantage point and interesting perspective, and obviously a very robust field in itself— one to which I thought I could contribute. That took me to Madras, and to the Madras High Court. I began by examining sources from the Madras High Court dating back to the cusp of independence around the 1940s. As I spent more time with these materials, I began to follow them across the oceans to Sri Lanka and Singapore.
While my own family’s history isn’t threaded through the book, families in south India will easily recognize themselves in the events and processes described in the book. I was very moved by the fact that like these places [Burma, Malaya, Singapore] which seem siloed off from the histories of South Asia [India, Sri Lanka] were not that far away then. These events and places remain ingrained in people’s family histories to this day. I certainly wanted to kind of take that seriously. My grandmother used to talk about family members who had to escape from Burma in 1942. Unfortunately, I never got to interview any of them as they all passed before I had the chance. I also recall my grandmother shared a short song in Tamil about escaping from Japanese air raids. Although it is woven into the fabric of most people’s lives in South India, we don’t often discuss it beyond these fragmented references. The project grew from there.
TD: This leads me to my second question about methodology, specifically how you utilize law as an archive. I wonder if you could elaborate a bit on the importance you give to international law. Tell our audience a little bit about how you frame international law as the centerpiece of this work, rather than, or as opposed to, let’s say imperial law or national law that emerged in the post-colonial decolonization moment?
KR: Yes, this is a super interesting question! It’s something that I have written about, not just in this book, but also as part of my Law and History Review piece. The distinction between imperial law, international law, and national law is not immediately evident. In other words, these are not categories that are already legible as such; the contours of what constitutes international law for those newly decolonized countries are something that’s being worked out in this moment. I cite Sundhya Pahuja and Luis Eslava’s work, both of which are fantastic pieces of scholarship, exactly on this point. I ground their idea about the relationship between states and international law in a historical context with a robust archival foundation. So, rather than write a history of international law that looks for an origin story, taking the category of “international law” and working backward, or writing a genealogy of sorts, I wanted to see what it meant for people to be engaged in a practice of international law. This is more explicit in the first couple of chapters, where I discuss cross-border legal disputes related to taxation and property, as well as the dissolution of partnerships resulting from wartime displacement.
The practice of international law is explored through the community of Nattukottai Chettiars, the subject of these two chapters. They had traded across the region for centuries, but decolonization and the emergence of new geopolitical borders made it difficult to continue doing business as before. Consequently, these litigants began invoking international law in their court arguments. The book discusses a case from Madras, alongside others in Burma and further afield, in which the language of occupation and government responsibility was used. It is not entirely clear what international law was doing in small civil court cases in Madras, or even at the High Court level. I interpret its use as evidence that people recognized the emergence of new states and understood themselves as belonging to them. They also recognized that interactions between states were governed by international law. This awareness extended beyond governments to mobile actors, who increasingly viewed international law as a means of advancing their claims and activities. As the book unfolds, questions of nationality, citizenship, and the governance of mobility increasingly become matters addressed through international law.
Histories of citizenship are typically confined to the provisions of a country’s constitution or its citizenship legislation. I think the book offers an alternative version of the story unfolding internationally, intertwined with the national narrative. One can clearly see the empire’s unraveling and its aftermath during this period, which is why I believe the use of international law in this context is important.

TD: This leads to my next question about the periodization. There is an idea of a missing period, for which I think you refer to Alison Bashford. Your book fills the gap in this period, spanning from 1942 to 1962. I thought that was quite interesting, because most colonial histories of South Asia typically end around 1945 or 1947. Post-colonial histories generally begin around 1947. To some extent, this is true not only of South Asian history but also of Southeast Asian history. Could you share with our readers your choice of periodization for the book?
KR: Great question. One of the things I was keen to explore in this book was periodization: first as a historiographical intervention, and then as a way of showing how law can be used to reconstruct history.
As you note, Alison Bashford’s work on migration and the color line across Canada, South Africa, and Australia is important here. We know the histories of the Komagata Maru’s journey to Vancouver and of Asiatic exclusion in Australia and South Africa, and we also have a rich body of scholarship on contemporary migration, citizenship, and governance. But what remains underexamined is the first wave of decolonization, when newly independent countries had to grapple with legal and political systems constructed in the aftermath of the World Wars. I wanted to place the South Asian stories within this wider global and regional context.
The book also moves beyond partitioned, siloed histories of South Asia. One of the most profound developments of this period, as Sunil Amrith notes, was the delinking of South Asia from Southeast Asia—the loosening of older networks, which I describe as “unraveling.” Connected histories often stop around the Japanese occupation, after which nationalist histories take over. I wanted instead to ask what it means to write a history of connections in an age of disconnection.
The year 1942 emerged from the archives as a starting point. It marked the Japanese occupation of Southeast Asia, the fall of Rangoon, and the Great or Long March from Burma into India. But it also became a juridical marker. People displaced by war later had to prove who they were, where they had been, and what claims they could make based on their location in 1942. In cases involving people from Burma or Ceylon who fled to India, 1942 repeatedly appears as a legal test of identity, loyalty, and belonging.
The book ends in 1962, but I do not see that as the end of the story. The military coup in Burma produced new displacement, but it also shows that displacement does not always follow a spectacular rupture. It can emerge through bureaucracy: higher permit fees, remittance restrictions, tighter procedures, and administrative uncertainty. Unlike Kenya or Uganda in 1972, there was no formal expulsion here, but a slow violence of paperwork and permits. Ultimately, the book treats 1942 as a juridical marker because many people experienced decolonization through legal disputes. Each case stretched decolonization further, forcing litigants to return to 1942 through documents and testimony.
In the conclusion, I emphasize that these issues remain ongoing. I found newspaper reports describing how Chettiars returned to Burma to reclaim their properties. Even today, many descendants of indentured laborers in Malaysia remain administratively stateless, while repatriated plantation laborers from Sri Lanka continue to face difficulties accessing welfare benefits or citizenship in India. Thus, 1962 is not the end of the story; it is simply where the book ends.
What I wanted to illustrate, then, were these intertwined political and legal temporalities. We may have our own political vocabulary and timelines for describing how decolonization unfolded, but that was not necessarily how everyone experienced it. For many, decolonization was not a single transfer of power or a neatly bounded historical moment, but an extended legal, bureaucratic, and emotional process.
TD: You organize the book around legal frameworks rather than the people affected by them; what led you to make that choice? I was also struck by the concise chapter titles, often just a year, word, or phrase—where did that idea come from?
KR: I am glad you noticed and appreciated the chapter titles, because I think my publisher would have preferred a more conventional way of naming them. You are also right that I wanted to organize the book by legal regimes rather than by groups of people—laborers, traders, and so on—which would have been an equally effective way to organize it. But that wasn’t what I wanted to do with the book. This approach of using legal regimes to organize the book was prompted by the fact that “migrants” are not the only label that can be applied to them.
The book examines the bureaucratic labels attached to its subjects. For people without legal training, distinctions between family law, civil law, and interstate taxation mattered little: it was all “law”. I wanted to convey the experience of standing before the law, embodied in the police station or the magistrate issuing a permit. Taxation, immigration, and deportation formed interlocking regimes. Someone declaring temporary residence on a remittance form to send money home might not anticipate consequences for naturalization, residence, or deportation. These paper trails could later be used against them. The book’s organization reflects how these legal and bureaucratic systems fed into one another. Inevitably, however, taxation archives from the 1940s contain far more traders than rickshaw pullers. That said, a colleague who also worked on Burma repatriates—Emma C. Meyer, who wrote a wonderful dissertation at Emory—mentioned that when she spoke with Burma repatriates in Visakhapatnam, they always claimed with pride that they had paid taxes in Burma. Later, during a conversation, Emma mentioned that when she read my book, she made the connection that tax was a way of indicating, on the part of these migrants, that they had paid dues to the country in which they had worked. This, in turn, made them feel entitled to stay, or entitled to go back and forth between these places in Southeast Asia and India.
For people who are moving back and forth, all of these things are interconnected, but they didn’t know that in 1942. It’s just something that kind of builds on itself. By 1962, it had become fairly certain that this was not a one-off case but rather a reflection of structures. So that’s why I wrote it in that fashion, so that as the reader goes along, they get that sense that this is something that’s getting built up. Hopefully, readers will see in the chapters that it isn’t only one group of people who are affected by this system. It continues to affect all those people who are moving back and forth, disproportionately in some cases.
As for the chapter titles, I wanted to draw attention to the paperwork in the book. Paperwork fluctuates in value, and states leveraged that fluctuation to decide who belongs and who does not. It was not always about passports. Tax receipts, application forms, or a union membership card all mattered. These disputes built on each other. The chapter titles reflect the more intimate scale on which this history is written.
TD: The book covers not only a wide temporal span but also a broad geography, moving across Burma, Ceylon, Malaya, Singapore, with Madras at its center. How did you navigate that scope? Were the shifts in focus across chapters—some more Burma-centric, others centered on Ceylon or Malaya—dictated by the archive, or were they a conscious structural choice?
KR: I like to think that it was mostly dictated by the archive in the sense that I was looking at sort of cross-border legal disputes. Initially, my method was simply to follow where the archival materials led. The book follows the dispute: if it unfolds in Rangoon, the narrative moves to Rangoon; if it remains at the Madras High Court, it stays in Madras; and if it travels to Ceylon, the book follows it there. There is also an analytical framework that I suggest through this method. Typically, when we think about writing legal history, or legal history as social history, or legal history as international history, we think of the hierarchy of courts. In such a paradigm, when a dispute moves from the trial level to the top court and is decided there, it takes on significance. Only the cases that rise to the top have any meaning or significance. I wanted to challenge that notion in two ways.
Firstly, that’s not necessarily how litigation proceeds, and certainly not in the case of disputes that move back and forth across jurisdictions. In property and taxation cases, simultaneous litigation was occurring in Malaya, Madras, and Burma, and lawyers were exchanging strategies. Similar arguments can be observed emerging across jurisdictions. Thus, it was not really a case of plotted legal history. It’s really a view from people who are engaged in this dispute, and what they saw as significant. Secondly, viewed through this lens, we can see how the history of citizenship and decolonization need not be about a shared metropole-colonial relationship but rather one that is more horizontal. Decolonization also signified negotiations between former colonies. These legal disputes really illuminate that resolution did not come only from London. It wasn’t always oriented that way, but the colonies were also looking to each other to figure out this moment of decolonization. I hope that this analytical framework emerges from organizing the book in a manner that allows for a back-and-forth approach among the various colonies—Burma, Ceylon, Malaya, and Madras. However, you are aware that the citizenship crisis in Ceylon didn’t fully emerge until 1954-56. It was not until 1964 that the first successful discussion between India and Sri Lanka took place over the impending statelessness of the Tamil-origin laborers. As time passes, I obviously have to shift the lens a little bit. But I hope what draws it all together is this perspective from Madras.
So, the story always circles back to Madras. However, that does mean some stories sometimes have to be left untold. For example, what was happening in Malaya and Singapore, well into the 1950s. That is not a story I can pursue because the trajectories of decolonization in Malaya, Singapore, and Indonesia are completely different from those in India, Burma, and Ceylon. The joy of writing a book like this is knowing there are other books that can be written. I settled on the idea that what I can do most usefully is to use these legal disputes as a means and the laws as a way to think differently about decolonization.
TD: Could you elaborate on your point that decolonization unfolded differently in Burma, Ceylon, and India than in Malaya and Singapore? Did the prolonged colonial intervention in Malaya and Singapore shape citizenship differently than the more hurried settlements in Burma, Ceylon, and India?
KR: The larger question is how we make sense of the differing temporalities of decolonization across these places, especially when people continued to move between them. Citizenship was debated in Malaya, Burma, Ceylon, and India, but it took different forms in each context. For instance, India gained independence in 1947 and Burma in 1948. Ceylon, by contrast, did not become a republic until 1972. My concern is that if we focus only on government schemes or constitutional timelines, we miss the more interesting story of people trying to make sense of a rapidly changing world. In such an approach, one can usefully ask questions about what it means to write a comparative history. How do we build on the scholarship from the 1970s about the place of Indian minorities in Burma and Malaya? From that perspective, I don’t think citizenship was necessarily easier in Malaya or Singapore. Similar concerns about belonging, indigeneity, fraud, and cutoff dates also shaped citizenship debates there. So, the book is one way of asking what other kinds of comparative histories of decolonization we might write. I am keen to work with a different set of materials to illuminate that. So, stay tuned!
TD: To take the conversation forward on Malaya, your chapter “Red Flags” is especially interesting. I was struck by how something akin to the Malayan Emergency was unfolding in Madras through the Maintenance of Public Order Act. Could you elaborate on the contradiction between postcolonial India’s solidarity with left-wing anti-colonial movements in Southeast Asia and its adoption of colonial-style policing techniques to suppress similar politics at home?
KR: There is a strong tradition of writing on the history of anti-colonial solidarities in the 1950s-1960s and on the possibilities for shared political futures among these newly decolonized countries. This scholarship is undoubtedly important. Around that time, discussions were certainly taking place, possibly due to the staggered nature of decolonization. Not all the countries were moving on the same track at the same time. India took a leading role, to some extent. For instance, the partnership between India and Indonesia. Here I am thinking of some great pieces by Carolien Stolte and Su Lin Lewis on the subject. Certainly, a lot of exciting scholarship is available from that perspective. I think what also remains to be explored in more detail is whether we were to step down from that scale and look at the missing piece of the puzzle.
For instance, we know from partition histories that Public Safety Acts were widely used. I am thinking here of Rotem Geva’s Delhi Reborn: Partition and Nation Building in India’s Capital, where, toward the end, she discusses Public Safety Acts, censorship, and preventive detention. Constitutional histories also show that such acts were often rubber-stamped by the courts and treated as acceptable restrictions on free speech and movement. In that sense, the Madras Maintenance of Public Order Act initially appeared to me as another version of this broader story.
But to return to your question about whether archives shaped my choices: in the archives, I expected the Madras Maintenance of Public Order Act (MPOA) to resemble similar acts elsewhere, such as in Punjab. Then I came across a remarkable file linking the MPOA to Malaya returnees. The fact that shared intelligence was used in policing, under a law ostensibly designed to curb communal violence after Partition, gives the story a very different complexion. It becomes a uniquely Madras story because the Act was used to curb political dissent. The Congress Party did not face an immediate electoral threat from either the Communist Party or the Dravidar Kazhagam, but the fleeting alliance between the two was seen as a problem. Added to this were laborers returning from Malaya with their own understanding of communism, creating suspicion and anxiety within the Congress Party about its electoral future.
But finally, it is not just a Madras story; it is a Madras-Malaya story. I could write about the MPOA because some Malaya returnees filed habeas corpus petitions before the Madras High Court. Madras was never their home. Even though they spoke Tamil or had South Indian-sounding names, many had never been to Madras before; they had been born in Malaya. In that sense, this is a very different story. It shows how the issue of Malaya returnees began to affect political and electoral calculations in Madras, though it eventually petered out. After 1967, Congress never again formed a ministry in Tamil Nadu, as Dravidian parties took over. The story, therefore, also marks the beginnings of Dravidian politics, an overlooked part of the puzzle, and helps clarify how these developments unfolded for people on the ground.
TD: Given the momentum for Third World solidarity after the Asian Relations Conference and Bandung, why did cooperation among newly decolonized states fail so sharply over citizenship and migration, and what does that failure reveal about the limits of both postcolonial internationalism and the Commonwealth as a substitute for empire?
KR: Yeah, it’s a great question. I honestly hadn’t thought about this implication, but now that you ask, I can see how the book addresses that issue as well. There are other works, perhaps better positioned to address this directly, such as Raphaëlle Khan and Taylor Sherman’s article in Modern Asian Studies. They show that there was a brief two-year period when Commonwealth membership was considered as an alternative, but it did not quite bear fruit.
Hopefully, the book demonstrates that several other schemes were proposed at the time. But this was not nostalgia for empire on the part of those caught up in questions of citizenship. It is true that they traveled within imperial networks to build lives across the Bay of Bengal, but movement across the bay long predated the empire. These were older routes, very different from histories of indenture. The oceanic voyages we need to consider were older and more prolonged over historical time. India and Sri Lanka, for instance, are not far apart, so we need a different framework rather than simply transposing existing models.
I think of this book not as a history of migration, but as an account of how histories of migration were leveraged in the service of citizenship. This part of the story has not received enough historiographical attention. At the time, there was serious soul-searching in India about what to do with overseas Indians. These questions of nationality, citizenship, and justice had to be addressed alongside the ramifications of Partition. As a result, Partition became encoded in constitutional provisions, leaving considerable ambiguity about the status of overseas Indians.
I had the opportunity to speak with someone who used to work at the Indian High Commission in Colombo as a stenographer. He was the person who typed up the Citizens Registry for people who wanted to become Indian citizens rather than choose Ceylonese citizenship. He told me he had to search through various laws, including the Constitution, to find provisions he could use. I have been working with him to write up that oral history.
What I gained from that interview was a real lack of clarity, both among newly independent nation-states and among their officials working on the ground. There was considerable ambiguity in India and Ceylon about how to make citizenship a reality for people moving back and forth. As historians working with archival records, we do not know what these people really wanted; we do not have access to that interiority. What we can see is that many were comfortable, and others were forced to, move along a spectrum of legal statuses ranging from citizenship to statelessness. They were not necessarily seeking one fixed citizenship. What mattered was mobility.
As I write in the book, displacement was not the loss of a single home; it was the loss of homes. Traders moving across the Palk Strait, for example, were often content to use temporary residence permits, a kind of long-term visa. They were not always looking for citizenship on either side. But eventually, it became impossible to live that way between places.
The book shows the schemes and strategies people used to preserve migrant rhythms and patterns of life. A history of citizenship told only through laws and constitutional provisions cannot capture this. These more intimate stories reveal a different account of displacement, dispossession, and ultimately decolonization.
TD: Can you tell us a little bit about your next project?
KR: My next book project, supported by ACLS and ISERP at Columbia, is about how disciplinary knowledges around law, science, and the environment shaped coastal livelihoods in Asia from the 1960s to the 2000s. I have published some sections of this research in Past and Present and Law and History Review.
TD: Thank you so much for taking the time to discuss this wonderful project. We will stay tuned for your next book.
Kalyani Ramnath is an Assistant Professor of History at Columbia University and the author of Boats in a Storm: Law, Migration, and Decolonization in South and Southeast Asia 1942–1962, published with Stanford University Press in 2023 and with Westland / Context in 2025. Her research and teaching interests are in legal history, histories of migration and displacement, transnational history, and questions of archival method.
Tathagata Dutta is an Editor-at-Large at the Toynbee Foundation and a Lecturer in the College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences at Auburn University at Montgomery. He specializes in the history of South and Southeast Asia, with particular interests in the histories of the Rohingya and Miya communities. His latest article on the subject is now available in The Journal of Asian Studies.


